| Male Recipient | High School | Year | Female Recipient | High School |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Joey Valenti | Leto | 1985 | Kim Parker | Chamberlain |
| Joey Valenti | Leto | 1986 | Patti Casey | Academy of Holy Names |
| Brett Phillips | Leto | 1987 | Lisa Fry | Chamberlain |
| Rich Biondi | Leto | 1988 | Korene Haladay | Armwood |
| Scott Lawler | King | 1989 | Tina Theis | Armwood |
| Mike Heald | Bloomingdale | 1990 | Alison Hayman | Tampa Catholic |
| Andy Alonso (tie) | Leto | 1991 | Bethany Tempel | Bloomingdale |
| Brian Crane (tie) | Jesuit | 1991 | ||
| Andrew Laverghetta | Bloomingdale | 1992 | Heather Ott | Bloomingdale |
| Tim Openlander | Armwood | 1993 | Stacia Masters | Leto |
| Christopher Newcomb | Armwood | 1994 | Adrienne Welsch | Chamberlain |
| Matthew Foxenberger | Leto | 1995 | Sabrina Thompson | Chamberlain |
| William Woodroffe | Berkeley Prep | 1996 | Emily Janns | Bloomingdale |
| Terry McCormick | Jesuit | 1997 | Christine Brady | Plant City |
| Christopher Gatlyn | Bloomingdale | 1998 | Jana Escribano | Bloomingdale |
| Casey Stump | Bloomingdale | 1999 | Hong-Van Le | East Bay |
| Richard “Blake” Dickenson | Durant | 2000 | Kellie Evans | Durant |
| Justin Trowbridge | Jesuit | 2001 | Tara Escribano | Bloomingdale |
| Don Jones | Tampa Bay Tech | 2002 | Jacqueline Hinton | Durant |
| Jason Poole | Brandon | 2003 | Ashley Quaid | Bloomingdale |
| Kevin Sachs | Berkeley Prep | 2004 | Emily Fedeles | Hillsborough |
| Nick Zimmerman | Wharton | 2005 | Callie Raymond | Berkeley Prep |
| Ogi Perucica | Wharton | 2006 | Caitlin Howard | Sickles |
| Brian Snuffer | Alonso | 2007 | Marissa Kazbour | Bloomingdale |
| Bobby Huertas | Freedom | 2008 | Rudi Rodriguez | Newsome |
| Freeman Bass | Durant | 2009 | Monique LaMotte | Freedom |
| Wes Sever | Tampa Prep | 2010 | Amber Famiglietti | Berkeley Prep |
| Tyler Hartlage | Jesuit | 2011 | Carly Keene | Steinbrenner |
| Brett Durrance | Jesuit | 2012 | Colby Maffei | Tampa Preparatory |
| Shaddy Douidar | Tampa Prep | 2013 | Caroline Bado | Plant |
| Michael Conlan | Jesuit | 2014 | Danielle Eule | Steinbrenner |
| Jake Van Der Luit | Newsome | 2015 | Lexie Ludy | Berkeley Prep |
| Connar Lufkin | Jesuit | 2016 | Julia Lester | Academy of Holy Names |
| Davinson Mera (tie) | Leto | 2017 | Ellie Laxer | Berkeley Prep |
| Clifford Adjei (tie) | Wharton | 2017 | ||
| Eric Ugarte | Plant City | 2018 | Caroline DeLisle | Wharton |
| John “Jack” Casey | Plant | 2019 | Emily Abdoney | Academy of Holy Names |
| Carson Bien | Jesuit | 2020 | Brooke Volpi (tie) | Robinson |
| 2020 | Makenzy Martin (tie) | Berkeley Prep | ||
| Marcello Valbuena | Tampa Catholic | 2021 | Quinn Ryan | Plant High School |
| Christian Fairchild | Jesuit High School | 2022 | Carsyn Martz | Berkeley Prep |
| Stephen Gilbert | Newsome High School | 2023 | Oivia Pielak | Berkeley Prep |
Donations can be made to:
Jose A. Alvarez Memorial Fund
605 Apollo Beach Blvd.
Apollo Beach, Florida 33572
OR